by Teresita Pumará
women are but the toys which amuse our lighter hours.
Sir Walter Scott.
I have a feeling, a feeling deep inside, a feeling I can’t hide. This
feeling tells me that the true main character in Walter Scott´s Ivanhoe is
Rebecca, the Jewish physician who cures Wilfred of Ivanhoe´s wounds, is then
kidnapped by a Templar knight and later saved from the stake by the grateful
Wilfred. Furthermore, I believe that the theme of the novel (at least one of
them) is the unrecognised role of women in medieval society. Surprisingly, like
no other male writer of his time and very few of ours, Sir Walter Scott appears
to be a feminist.
Here I want to apologize to all scholars of English
literature, because I am writing with no serious investigative knowledge on the
subject. I read the novel thoroughly and was deeply surprised by the writer´s
subtle intelligence and clarity of judgement. I will try, nevertheless, to
support my feeling deep inside by bringing forward how the narrator depicts
women and how he depicts the way his male characters relate to women. To
everybody´s comfort I will often refer to the narrator with the author´s name.
I
Rebecca is the daughter of Isaac of York, a Jewish usurer. Although
her father presents some of the typical traits of Jewish characters in European
literature, Rebecca on the contrary shows none of them. She is calm and
self-assured, but sensible and generous. And when Sir Walter reveals her
ability as a physician I immediately noticed the absence of a remark about the
relation between the healer´s genre and her capacity. Not once does he say, “she
was clever or skilled despite being a woman” or “she had a masculine mind”,
neither he censors or punishes her for her knowledge. Furthermore: he gives
Rebecca a female master.
I cannot but compare this to the way Balzac depicts
women. The French writer often refers to women in general as the “weak sex”.
This weakness means usually that they require the support and protection of
men, and that they fall easily to the temptation of earthly pleasures, and drag
men with them. The classic pattern. The uncommonly cultivated women in Balzac´s
novels are silenced. If they are wise they hide willingly their disturbing
knowledge. In Albert Savarus Balzac explicitly praises this
attitude and wonders if it is better to educate women and so risk to produce
demons, or not to educate them and leave them victims of their passions.
II
Regarding the male characters, Sir Walter shows them as spoiled
children when it comes to women. Whenever a woman does not do as they wish, they
scowl and call them ungrateful. How is it possible that you don´t like me?,
they ask in much subtler ways. How can you be so cold and defensive after I
kidnapped you and repeatedly expressed my wish to rape you? What is better is
that there is no need for the narrator to pass judgement about his characters
actions. Their doings and words are enough.
Towards the last part of the novel, for example,
Brian de Bois-Guilbert, a Knight of the Temple, falls for Rebecca, kidnaps her and
hides her in the Templar convent. At the same time, the Templar Grandmaster
arrives to bring the Order back to order, so to say. When Rebecca´s father
comes to offer a ransom for his daughter, the Grandmaster discovers that the
licentious Bois-Guilbert keeps hidden a Jewish woman, who is the known disciple
of a burnt sorceress. The preceptor of the convent, who is a friend of the
guilty knight, finds then the way to save his friend and himself by blaming the
woman. She has bewitched the valiant knight, he says. He is but a victim and
he, the preceptor, has allowed her presence in the convent only to control the
situation and prevent the poor knight from falling in further sin. The fanatic
Grandmaster obviously loves the story and calls Rebecca to judgement.
III
But what makes Sir Walter in Ivanhoe a complete
feminist, with the negative load all idealism implies, is that Rebecca has no
flaw. She is the only character in the novel who never shows a moment of
weakness. For example, when she is facing the stake and the Templar knight
offers her to escape together, she rejects him with not one moment of doubt. By
denying Rebecca the right to fail a little to herself, at least to doubt about
what she holds sacred, Sir Walter makes an angel of her and not a woman, a
human being. By doing so he places her in an unreachable position. And so it
seems to us, the women who read the novel, that to be an honourable woman is
never to fail. Some women understood female liberation this way and plunged
into life trying to comply with all of what society demanded of them. They
became successful professionals, but also beautiful desirable women, good
mothers, of course, and attentive housewives. They are Rebecca. It is time, I
think, to fail a little bit, step down of the pedestal, and come out of
hell.